The Genesee Theatre
Their pricing and package information is a little more difficult than usual to decipher, but The Genesee Theatre seems relatively affordable to me. The coordinator who contacted me was really friendly, which is a good sign!
It’s really cool to be married on the stage with stage lighting and everything, everyone eating on the stage would give you the opp for some really cool pictures.
Not sure yet if this one makes the top five, but it’s definitely one of the most well-maintained looking old-theatres I’ve seen in Illinois, and it seems really affordable.